{"edition_date":"2026-11-02","edition_no":45,"headline":"Five videos, 4.4k comments. The room ran 33% positive, and almost none of it looked automated.","teaser":"A Team Fortress 2 player pointed out that a new game mode arrived before GTA 6.","url":"https://paiddev.com/comments/2026-11-02","published_at":"2026-11-02T20:46:20.581+00:00","stats":{"ytUnits":128,"geminiIn":24027,"topEmoji":[{"char":"❤","count":299},{"char":"🔥","count":260},{"char":"😂","count":252}],"geminiOut":599,"busiestHour":null,"mostNegative":"VFm9DRwr33A","mostPositive":"u_hpZueWI9g","neutralShare":0.6373453318335208,"videosPicked":5,"mostAutomated":"4snV6gVQXMA","negativeShare":0.030596175478065243,"positiveShare":0.332058492688414,"videosSkipped":0,"videosAnalyzed":5,"automationShare":0.0040494938132733405,"commentsAnalyzed":4445},"videos":[{"video_id":"u_hpZueWI9g","title":"TREASURE - ‘SHOCK’ M/V","channel":"TREASURE (트레저)","youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u_hpZueWI9g","permalink":"https://paiddev.com/comments/v/u_hpZueWI9g","chart_tier":"plain","summary":"This is a music video for the song Shock by the group Treasure. The video features the group members performing synchronized choreography in various settings, including a tunnel, a courtyard, and a rooftop. The mood is intense and energetic, with frequent cuts between different locations and dramatic lighting effects. The video concludes with the group members dancing together in a dark, enclosed space.","analysis":{"comments_analyzed":1000,"positive_share":0.428,"neutral_share":0.56,"negative_share":0.012,"automation_share":0.006,"automation_confidence":"high","themes":["Asahi rapping","YG style","performance talent"],"vibe":"Everyone is collectively losing their minds because Asahi finally has a rap verse."},"featured":[{"role":"funniest","text":"2:31 WHAT JEONGWOO???\nSeriously, I was really shocked that you were flirting like that 😫😭❤️‍🔥","author":"@金本_Cherlyy","like_count":2,"why":"Jeongwoo is seen interacting with the camera in a flirtatious way at the 2:31 timestamp.","removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u_hpZueWI9g&lc=UgwGtpO4xgD7wiJnQ1p4AaABAg"},{"role":"runner_up","text":"junkyu pasti iri liat member pada keren & ganteng (mengetik dalam keadaan kangen banget sama junkyu dan berharap dia segera kembali❤)","author":"@Bonbonjun","like_count":0,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u_hpZueWI9g&lc=Ugwv5uprXoCF0sgNHCl4AaABAg"},{"role":"runner_up","text":"pulang kerja, dikasih yang ganteng² gini, wooo ya boleh, wong dikasih","author":"@wolpe__","like_count":1,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u_hpZueWI9g&lc=UgysneebgZn7yG0yo-14AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"1:24 ASAHI LITERALLY RAP!! 🫵😭😭","author":"@amnilestari4358","like_count":4718,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u_hpZueWI9g&lc=Ugz7iqhFhIQs-FoCTml4AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"Imagine debuting almost 7 years ago and still not having a single bad song or choreography. Proud to be treasure maker","author":"@knmtrxr","like_count":3562,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u_hpZueWI9g&lc=UgwNIqphO0R0OZ-1cxl4AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"10 rappers +  10 vocalist + 10  dancers + 10visuals + 10kings = TREASURE","author":"@SeoulsSilentSpring","like_count":2864,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u_hpZueWI9g&lc=UgyfW506vmPq0vKhVFR4AaABAg"}]},{"video_id":"VFm9DRwr33A","title":"PLAYING ROBLOX INSIDE OF ROBLOX..","channel":"Foltyn","youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VFm9DRwr33A","permalink":"https://paiddev.com/comments/v/VFm9DRwr33A","chart_tier":"plain","summary":"The video features a creator named Foltyn playing a Roblox game that involves playing Roblox within the platform. Viewers are reacting to the content by expressing their fandom and sharing personal updates in the comments.","analysis":{"comments_analyzed":924,"positive_share":0.2846320346320346,"neutral_share":0.658008658008658,"negative_share":0.05735930735930736,"automation_share":0.006493506493506494,"automation_confidence":"high","themes":[],"vibe":"Most of the room stayed neutral."},"featured":[{"role":"funniest","text":"Hahaha the way he said are you happy and the robot said no in 5:12😂😂","author":"@estelagarcia2029","like_count":0,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VFm9DRwr33A&lc=UgwIeDu7MeWlAJW0HzN4AaABAg"},{"role":"runner_up","text":"The intro is so guys today were goona play Roblox inside of Roblox um yeah i dint stutter so this game is app app NEVERMIND 😂😂😂","author":"@humphreykimemia4108","like_count":0,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VFm9DRwr33A&lc=UgwQ65Csu6i-VdiDyVl4AaABAg"},{"role":"runner_up","text":"My friend: the world is crazy!\nMe: no, roblox is crazy...","author":"@ReubenKurland","like_count":0,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VFm9DRwr33A&lc=UgzOff-b_ueohntuiMV4AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"Broo, it feels great to be back. Yes, I apologize. This school is keeping me busy. It is day 95 of asking Foltyn to visit Georgia (a small country). In Georgia, I live in Senaki. I am your biggest fan, and I really want to meet you in real life or on Roblox. It feels so good to be back...","author":"@lexymyla","like_count":427,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VFm9DRwr33A&lc=UgyiXzlENsuREKFd3_F4AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"👈 *Who's neeids RBX on 01 November 2026?....* 🍿🌳🌊🍌","author":"@OlivaRekline","like_count":141,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VFm9DRwr33A&lc=Ugx9s-usAW9ip-BTq754AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"Foltyn fan here \n👇","author":"@christiansmith221","like_count":130,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VFm9DRwr33A&lc=UgzXIuSEOMIyBaw7uZN4AaABAg"}]},{"video_id":"NbJnQP8Zo2E","title":"Upgrading Crafting - Sky Factory Season 7 EP 8","channel":"SSundeePlus","youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NbJnQP8Zo2E","permalink":"https://paiddev.com/comments/v/NbJnQP8Zo2E","chart_tier":"plain","summary":null,"analysis":{"comments_analyzed":1000,"positive_share":0.385,"neutral_share":0.584,"negative_share":0.031,"automation_share":0,"automation_confidence":"high","themes":["nostalgic channel intros","recurring video bits","childhood memories"],"vibe":"The comment section is obsessed with the nostalgia of the old intro and constant petitions for specific recurring bits."},"featured":[{"role":"funniest","text":"0:30 nope sorry sundee ya gonna be 80 and still doing this shit 😂","author":"@kaptainkoala911noah9","like_count":0,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NbJnQP8Zo2E&lc=UgxJUxh20Ac9DEcxO5J4AaABAg"},{"role":"runner_up","text":"Funny how ATM team got mad at the series being called \"skyfactory\" but has a skyfactory world preset in the game 😂😂","author":"@hopemanuel9991","like_count":0,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NbJnQP8Zo2E&lc=Ugw6zSSCna_-NI1qnER4AaABAg"},{"role":"runner_up","text":"I said the intro word for word 😭😭😂😂","author":"@jasonerasmus4321","like_count":0,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NbJnQP8Zo2E&lc=UgxHCqrYzqDPNPSLsJ94AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"petition for ssundee to do “hey guys ssundee here” every sky factory episode 🙏","author":"@bl3cks.45","like_count":20665,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NbJnQP8Zo2E&lc=UgwPV5MiHsnqrwXs8rB4AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"Patition for ssundee to do \"IVE BEEN BUSY BETWEEN EPISODES\" every episode","author":"@TheProPetar","like_count":6530,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NbJnQP8Zo2E&lc=UgzsRf1e28FjSJJgjBB4AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"I’m lowkey abused","author":"@Roman_Bearman","like_count":4138,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NbJnQP8Zo2E&lc=UgwnTvc7NCdA9AoukzJ4AaABAg"}]},{"video_id":"4snV6gVQXMA","title":"How to Find the *FREE* ITEM SHOP Pirate Token (Best Landing Spot)","channel":"TG Plays","youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4snV6gVQXMA","permalink":"https://paiddev.com/comments/v/4snV6gVQXMA","chart_tier":"plain","summary":"This video provides a guide on how to locate a rare item known as the Pirate Token within a game. Viewers are discussing their experiences with the item's extremely low drop rate, comparing it to other rewards like the golden A$AP Rocky cosmetics, and sharing strategies for opening chests to increase their chances of finding it.","analysis":{"comments_analyzed":521,"positive_share":0.1381957773512476,"neutral_share":0.8119001919385797,"negative_share":0.04990403071017274,"automation_share":0.007677543186180422,"automation_confidence":"high","themes":["item shop token","low drop rates","fortnite grinding"],"vibe":"The community is mostly just frustrated by the absurdly low drop rates for the pirate token."},"featured":[{"role":"funniest","text":"So you don't have the pirate token thing but you're making a video on how to get it. 😂","author":"@Gigi7thy","like_count":0,"why":"The video provides a guide for an item that the creator does not actually possess.","removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4snV6gVQXMA&lc=Ugzx9NHhGYn0aie-Goh4AaABAg"},{"role":"runner_up","text":"All these streamers giving us ideas yet haven't got it them selfs 🤡's 🤣🤣🤣","author":"@far.q1370","like_count":0,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4snV6gVQXMA&lc=Ugwc9ciwey2cI1_2Rn94AaABAg"},{"role":"runner_up","text":"Most streamers got it. Normal players will grind and never get one. Thats the way fortnite made it so people will play more 😂","author":"@kylewallis31","like_count":0,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4snV6gVQXMA&lc=Ugz2igixvifnRhZbRr54AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"I have the pickax, the loading screen, and the jam track","author":"@flossonthem","like_count":221,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4snV6gVQXMA&lc=UgxVtksxFkllT2V1g1x4AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"apparently the gold ASAP rocky skin is even rarer than the shop token","author":"@NicoTheTurkey12","like_count":209,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4snV6gVQXMA&lc=UgwHOLP0IB1DyYXnFVR4AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"For anyone wondering, it gives u free access to permanenltly buy anything from the item shop for free, this does not mean the stuff u get will get taken away once the 14 days are over, what u claim is yours and yours forever, and every day the item shop refreshes, so you can get a few different things everyday for that first 14 days, and this will work once in 2026 and once in 2027","author":"@tsatic","like_count":193,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4snV6gVQXMA&lc=UgzVooONPC_93_DLWoJ4AaABAg"}]},{"video_id":"2V3wsgg71u8","title":"Mann Versus Zombies - Gameplay Trailer","channel":"Breadworks","youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2V3wsgg71u8","permalink":"https://paiddev.com/comments/v/2V3wsgg71u8","chart_tier":"plain","summary":"This gameplay trailer shows characters from the game Team Fortress 2 fighting against waves of zombies in a dark, post-apocalyptic city. The characters use various weapons and special abilities to defend themselves against large groups of undead enemies and a massive boss creature. The video concludes with the characters standing on a pile of defeated zombies while a large, glowing bomb detonates in the background.","analysis":{"comments_analyzed":1000,"positive_share":0.328,"neutral_share":0.658,"negative_share":0.014,"automation_share":0.002,"automation_confidence":"high","themes":["left dead","team fortress","call duty"],"vibe":"Most of the room stayed neutral."},"featured":[{"role":"funniest","text":"Jajajajaja salió un nuevo modo en TF2 antes que GTA 6 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣","author":"@adamspeck1796","like_count":0,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2V3wsgg71u8&lc=UgzrJBQFEKRUVz5apUB4AaABAg"},{"role":"runner_up","text":"Seeing that gibus engineer put up a fight was kind of cute and sad....😭😭","author":"@randomencountersteelix","like_count":0,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2V3wsgg71u8&lc=UgzzOrEubGV5Nonezo54AaABAg"},{"role":"runner_up","text":"Woah TF2 being the new cod zombies was not in my bucket list. 😂 ill play this please. 👏","author":"@brianblue6933","like_count":0,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2V3wsgg71u8&lc=UgzY9HupFx5CGaV-K-p4AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"The Meet the Medic map being in this mod is beautiful","author":"@TheKnownspy","like_count":9418,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2V3wsgg71u8&lc=UgyomcaBVEmdSKE6Ph14AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"This is so freaking beautiful","author":"@YahiamiceLIVE","like_count":5459,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2V3wsgg71u8&lc=UgzfIqZLSo5n3_PD3_14AaABAg"},{"role":"top","text":"0:30 No way, Medic finally realized he can actually use a gun instead of a peashooter syringe gun","author":"@DaftSpunky","like_count":3649,"why":null,"removed":false,"youtube_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2V3wsgg71u8&lc=Ugy4J1S2Cw6IU0Rgnu94AaABAg"}]}],"skipped":[],"disclosure":"Sentiment, themes and automation figures are PAID LLC's own estimates computed from public comments. They are not YouTube metrics, and they describe each comment section in aggregate, never any individual account. Comment text, video titles and statistics come from YouTube and belong to their authors. Not affiliated with or endorsed by YouTube. Method: https://paiddev.com/comments/about"}